The ethics of "bootlegging"

Forum Forums General Discussions The ethics of "bootlegging"

Viewing 2 posts - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1086
    Bill Whitaker wrote:

    >Bootlegging to me

    is commercial size operations making big bucks as was rife not long ago

    >in places like Hong Kong, not people swapping their own off-air

    recordings but I suppose not >all will agree with me there.

    As someone who made a (modest) contribution to the show, as Music Advisor for the last two series, please let me jump in and cheer this to the rafters – EXACTLY. Not just with Onedin Line. From time to time, I see my BBC radio shows on Usenet – and I'm always delighted to see them there, because that is where the real fans are – just like here. Similarly, I see the occasional glimpse of myself on YouTube. If the BBC can't get it together to put this stuff out, those people who watched us week in, week out the first time out (or who want to discover the show anew) should be allowed to use whatever means they can to get hold of the shows – because who will be first to the stores when the official issue comes out (if it does)? Precisely. Those unofficial issues create new fans and keep us alive in the hearts of old ones. Obviously, when sales get into 5 or 6 figures, then we need to talk – but the people we need to talk to are at the BBC.

    By the way, I was clearing my basement yesterday, and came across an autograph card of Laura Hartong. Now, there's someone I haven't thought of for a while. Very American and utterly unrecognisable out of costume …

    Bill Scanlan Murphy

    [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

    #1087
    ivaradi
    Keymaster
    — In shiponedingroup@yahoogroups.com, William Murphy
    <lobsanghoskins@…> wrote:

    >
    > Bill Whitaker wrote:
    >
    > >Bootlegging to me
    > is commercial size operations making big bucks as was rife not long

    ago

    > >in places like Hong Kong, not people swapping their own off-air
    > recordings but I suppose not >all will agree with me there.
    >
    > As someone who made a (modest) contribution to the show, as Music

    Advisor for the last two series, please let me jump in and cheer this
    to the rafters – EXACTLY. Not just with Onedin Line. From time to
    time, I see my BBC radio shows on Usenet – and I'm always delighted
    to see them there, because that is where the real fans are – just
    like here. Similarly, I see the occasional glimpse of myself on
    YouTube. If the BBC can't get it together to put this stuff out,
    those people who watched us week in, week out the first time out (or
    who want to discover the show anew) should be allowed to use whatever
    means they can to get hold of the shows – because who will be first
    to the stores when the official issue comes out (if it does)?
    Precisely. Those unofficial issues create new fans and keep us alive
    in the hearts of old ones. Obviously, when sales get into 5 or 6
    figures, then we need to talk – but the people we need to talk to are
    at the BBC.

    >
    > By the way, I was clearing my basement yesterday, and came across

    an autograph card of Laura Hartong. Now, there's someone I haven't
    thought of for a while. Very American and utterly unrecognisable out
    of costume …

    >
    > Bill Scanlan Murphy
    >

    Dear Bill,

    I am just watching series 4(?) where Charlotte as a child has
    diptheria. She has passed the crisis (sighs of relief abound). Was
    Laura Hartong popular enough at the time to generate autograph cards?
    There is a Laura Hartong on Facebook with a photo, but I don't see
    much resemblance – how old would she be now?? Was she American?
    Cheers and happy holidays to all Onedinites. Anybody know whatever
    happened to Mary Webster??

    >
    >
    >
    >
    > [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
    >

Viewing 2 posts - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.